I've observed aperture glitches in most of the Panasonic and Olympus zoom lenses I've tested. My conclusion is that none of these lenses are built with a mechanically constant aperture - they all use electronic iris control to simulate the aperture you select. This includes the following lenses:
Olympus 35-100mm f2.0
Olympus 14-54mm f2.8-3.5
Olympus 9-18mm f4-5.6
Panasonic 14-50mm f2.8-3.5
Panasonic 14-45mm f3.5-5.6
Panasonic 45mm-200mm f4-5.6
Panasonic 14-140mm f4-5.8
Panasonic 45-175mm f4-5.6
What happens when you zoom is the camera detects the altered focal length and electronically adjusts the iris to dynamically maintain the aperture you've selected. But in practice, the iris is not stepless and occasionally clicks when adjusted. What's worse is that since the camera is unable to track continuous zooming in real time, dynamic iris adjustments often lag behind the zoom.
@Vitaliy_Kiselev, thanks for the advice. I'll do it.
sorry, I don't get your point. What do you mean?
I mean - cover the lens contacts and film zooming in.
@Vitaliy_Kiselev sorry, I don't get your point. What do you mean? Anyway, is my opinion correct that this is a "fake" constant f/2.8 lens?
Does it really mean it's a fake constant f/2.8 lens?
You can cover the contacts and check :-)
@Vitaliy_Kiselev, would you be so kind to comment your thoughts on the thing I sad:
"Yesterday I looked at the front mount of my lens and noticed the following. I set f/2.8 and started zooming in. The more I zoom in, the more the aperture squeezes".
Does it really mean it's a fake constant f/2.8 lens?
@sam_rides_a_mtb it's very easy to find it out.
You gotta zoom in and after that focus on some object. Then zoom out (and remember to stand on the same place). Then (standing on the same place) zoom in onto the same object. If this object is still in focus then your lens is parfocal.
@Mikhailk How do you know this lens is parfocal? From doing your own tests or did you read this somewhere?
@nomad, this lens is parfocal.
@stonebat, Yesterday I looked at the front mount of my lens and noticed the following. I set f/2.8 and started zooming in. The more I zoom in, the more the aperture squeezes. Maybe I'm wrong but I have a conclusion that @Vitaliy_Kiselev was right:
"As issue can be just with lens firmware error. It tries to keep F number during zooming, but fail to do it properly. ------- So, it can be non-constant F number zoom with electronic adjustment. ------- "
Also you should keep in mind that during zooming with this lens while taking photos, you clearly hear the lens' motor and see this flicker effect. When you zoom in the cinema mode (without pressing the REC button) you also here this sound and see the same flicker effect. When you press the REC button this sound almost disappears, but this flicker effect is still there (it's getting less noticable but it's there).
Does anyone know if when mounted on a Af100 and you adjust the iris if it's "hard" click like steps or is it smooth like a built in lens? I had the 14-35mm f2 which optically was great but if you were outside and the sun was moving in and out and you had to adjust the iris it pretty much killed the take.
Those who wanna have a true "cinematic" zooming (without the brightness change) while shooting a movie/video, may forget about this lens.
This thing needs carefully testing to understand why this happens.
As issue can be just with lens firmware error. It tries to keep F number during zooming, but fail to do it properly.
So, it can be non-constant F number zoom with electronic adjustment.
Thanks a lot for the confirmation. I also forgot to say that this effect (brightness changes in step) comes with a sound, as you said.
I don't know about you or others who have this lens, but I'm very disappointed 'cause this lens is not a cheap one.
@Vitaliy_Kiselev, yes, it's a bad sign. Those who wanna have a true "cinematic" zooming (without the brightness change) while shooting a movie/video, may forget about this lens.
Unfortinately I can't upload a file for you to see it but trust me, this lens has it.
This is quite bad sign.
Hi everybody,
I've just tested my new Panasonic 12-35mm and I'd like to share with you some things I didn't like about this lens...
The good points are for video-shooters:
But, since most of us here on Personal-View are interested in video/cinema shooting, there are several things you won't like about this lens:
This effect reminds me the same thing when you zoom in/out using a non-constant aperture lens. Of course, this effect is not that huge but you'll notice. Unfortinately I can't upload a file for you to see it but trust me, this lens has it.
@bkmcwd, I would appreciate if you could confirm my words, since you do have the same lens already.
@Vitaliy_Kiselev that would be a huge thing :) do you speak in terms of panasonic implementing it, or do you see a potential for investigating it?
It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!